Jayne's Baby Bank

Volunteering or Paid Work? The Store Credit Controversy at JBB

Avatar photo By Sherlock 6 min read

The short version

  • Jayne’s Baby Bank rewards its “volunteers” with store credit for set shifts: £20, £25, £40 or £50 a shift, or £30 a week for managers. By March 2026 it was “£13 an hour in stock allowance”.
  • The credit is “ONLY GRANTED IF HOURS ARE WORKED”, and her posts talk of being “a worker”, “shift patterns” and being “entitled”.
  • GOV.UK says you might be classed as a worker rather than a volunteer if you get “any other payment, reward or benefit in kind” beyond expenses. Workers are owed the minimum wage.
  • She tells volunteers it “won’t affect benefits/hmrc/tax credits as it is a gesture of good will from myself”. Calling it goodwill does not decide the legal position.
  • People on benefits are told by the DWP to report any volunteering to their benefits office before they start.

The rates

On 18 April 2025 her page posted its “Volunteers rates of allowance” (the post):

Volunteers rates of allowance. ♻️♻️ONLY GRANTED IF HOURS ARE WORKED AND STAFF ARE WORKING.♻️♻️ They are the shift patterns to be entitled to the allowance. If the hours are not covered then there is no allowance. WE NEED these shifts covered unfortunately. … WE ARE NOT ROLLING OVER ALLOWANCE. £20 – 75% DISCOUNT £5 cost to baby bank £25 – 75% DISCOUNT £6.25 cost to baby bank £40 – 75% DISCOUNT £10 cost to baby bank £50 – 75% DISCOUNT £12.50 cost to baby bank

Her page, 18 April 2025

The rates sheet with that post set out the weekend shifts: “£40 store credit 9am–5pm (8-hour shift), £50 store credit 5pm–10pm, free micro meal and snacks and drinks.” Another attachment was a weekly time sheet, with spaces for the “name of employee”, overtime and an “employee signature”.

A blank Weekly Time Sheet with columns for morning, afternoon and overtime in and out times, regular and overtime hours, and lines for name of employee and employee signature. No person permitted to work overtime without special authorization
The weekly time sheet with her April 2025 post: “name of employee”, overtime, and “employee signature”.

Earlier posts show the same pattern. In October 2024: “We pay our managers £30 in stock a week … You need to be a worker” (the post). In November 2024, advertising for cleaners: “We can pay you in stock. We won’t pay cash or wages. Then it won’t affect benefits/tax credits/tax” (the post). In April 2025: “Volunteers get minimum £20 of stock allowance a shift but you have to be working. We don’t need sitting arounders” (the post).

Volunteer or worker?

GOV.UK is clear about what a volunteer can receive (volunteering: pay and expenses):

You are not paid for your time as a volunteer, but you may get money to cover expenses. This is usually limited to food, drink, travel or any equipment you need to buy. … You might be classed as an employee or worker rather than a volunteer if you get any other payment, reward or benefit in kind.

GOV.UK

HMRC’s National Minimum Wage manual says the same (NMWM05080):

Any payments made to volunteers (particularly if they are made regularly), expenses greater than can be realistically incurred, or entitlement to benefits in kind could indicate that the person is not a volunteer, even if they think they are, but is actually a worker and will be entitled to the National Minimum Wage.

HMRC, National Minimum Wage manual

Store credit for set shifts, only “if hours are worked”, is regular and conditional, and it is a benefit in kind. If the people doing those shifts are workers, they are owed at least the minimum wage, and the business takes on duties such as tax, National Insurance and holiday pay. Employment lawyers such as Tozers give the same warning.

“A gesture of goodwill”

She has told volunteers more than once that the credit will not affect their tax or benefits:

This is declared to HMRC and DWP as a gesture of goodwill from myself. This should not affect your tax or benefits.

Her page, 2 February 2025 (the post)

Paid in stock and it won’t affect benefits/hmrc/tax credits as it is a gesture of good will from myself.

Her page, 23 March 2025 (the post)

Volunteers that work a full shift are entitled to £20 store credit a day. This is not taxable or won’t affect pensions, or benefits or pip as it is a gesture of goodwill from myself.

Her page, 19 June 2025 (the post)

Calling a payment “goodwill” does not change what it is. A reward that is promised in advance, for set hours, and only if the hours are worked looks like payment, and is likely to be treated as payment. Nor is “declared to HMRC and DWP” something she can do on a volunteer’s behalf: tax and benefits depend on each person’s own records and reporting. The Low Incomes Tax Reform Group lists “a benefit in kind, like a voucher” among the payments that can count, and warns organisations against paying “blanket allowances” (payments to volunteers).

Volunteers on benefits

People who claim Universal Credit, ESA or other benefits can volunteer, but the DWP tells them to report it to their benefits office before they start, including their hours and days (volunteering and claiming benefits). A regular stock allowance is not the same as unpaid volunteering. Anyone who takes it while on means-tested or disability benefits, relying on her word that it “won’t affect” them, could be putting their benefits at risk.

Not a charity

Jayne’s Baby Bank is not a registered charity. The Charity Commission told the council that one application was never completed and another was refused (the subject access request). Its signs and branding have still used the words “charity shop”; the difference is explained in charity shops vs charity status.

What happened next

The language moved further towards pay. On 30 August 2025: “if you are a worker and get stuck in – you get £20 a day allowance to buy items in the shop as a gesture of goodwill” (the post). And on 16 March 2026, inviting corporate volunteers (the post):

We pay our volunteers £13 an hour in stock allowance as a gesture of goodwill* (Needs to be declared as a gesture if goodwill to tax and Dwp).

Her page, 16 March 2026

An hourly rate, paid for hours worked, is the language of a wage. You can find every time she talks about allowances and credit in our transcript search.

Volunteering matters to many community causes. But it has to be run lawfully and openly, in a way that protects the volunteers as well as the public. We have seen how she treats former volunteers who fall out with her. Getting it wrong risks legal trouble, harm to vulnerable people and confusion for donors.

Sources

…Sherlock

Know someone who should read this?

Last updated

Read next

Menu

Search the articles

For her own posts and videos, use Search.

Tap where you want to zoom in. Tap again to fit.