Jayne's Baby Bank

Charity Shops vs. Charity Status: Understanding the Differences

Avatar photo By Sherlock 5 min read

The short version

  • On 27 June 2024 she was asked: “Are you registered as a charity now?” Her answer: “You don’t need to be a registered charity to be a baby bank or a food bank.”
  • That is true of a baby bank. But the business was also called a charity shop: on her own Facebook profile, on its Newport Facebook group, on its pages and in listings and the press.
  • The Charity Retail Association’s guidance said: “Only registered charities can set up charity shops.”
  • Small charities can stay unregistered, but only while their income is £5,000 a year or less. By her own account, she had more than £8,000 from councils in 2024 alone.
  • In 2022 she said the shops were “going through the registration process”, and that the name would change “once we are a charity and CIC”. Jayne’s Baby Bank has never been a registered charity.

The question

On 27 June 2024 someone asked Jayne’s Baby Bank on Facebook a straightforward question: “Are you registered as a charity now?” Miss Ridsdale answered herself (the post):

Her post: Don't know how many times I have to say it! You don't need to be a registered charity to be a baby bank or a food bank. We are registered with 3 Councils. Its up to ME if I want to give the profit made from my shops back to the public and not keep it. I have chosen to give 100% of the proceeds made daily to Jayne'sBaby Bank
Her post, 27 June 2024. Read it in our archive.

“Charity Shop”, in her own name

Her answer talks about a baby bank and a food bank. It leaves out the third thing the business called itself: a charity shop. Her own Facebook profile said she “Works at Jayne’s Mother and Baby Bank, Food Bank and Charity Shop”.

Her personal Facebook profile: Works at Jayne's Mother and Baby Bank, Food Bank and Charity Shop
Her Facebook profile, June 2024.

Other public sources called it a charity shop too. A few examples:

Neighbourly, the community giving platform: “We own 4 registered FREE foodbanks and baby banks along side 4 Charity Shop” (the listing).

Neighbourly listing: We own 4 registered FREE foodbanks and baby banks along side 4 Charity Shop. We help families all over the UK and Africa and the Ukraine
The Neighbourly listing.

Moovit, the travel app: directions to “Jayne’s Baby Bank & Charity Shop (Torfaen)” (the listing).

Moovit: Directions to Jayne's Baby Bank and Charity Shop (Torfaen) with public transport
The Moovit listing.

The South Wales Argus: “Each shop is equipped with a baby bank, charity shop, and a food bank” (the article).

South Wales Argus article: the shops are in Risca, Blackwood, Pontypool and Brynmawr. Each shop is equipped with a baby bank, charity shop, and a food bank
The South Wales Argus.

Its Facebook group, created on 21 May 2022 as “Jayne’s Baby Bank & Charity Shop Newport Free Page” and renamed two months later (the group).

Facebook group history: created on 21 May 2022 as Jayne's Baby Bank and Charity Shop Newport Free Page, renamed on 27 July 2022 to Jayne's Baby Bank SOUTH WALES Free Page
The group’s history, as Facebook shows it.

Its earlier Facebook page, “Jayne’s Mother & Baby Bank, Food Bank & Charity Shop”, which advertised the Aberbargoed shop in 2022 (the page’s pictures, in our gallery).

Facebook post of 10 September 2022 by the page Jayne's Mother and Baby Bank, Food Bank and Charity Shop: Jayne's Baby Bank, 35 Bowen Industrial Estate, Aberbargoed, 10am to 4pm Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday
The page’s post, 10 September 2022.

Its TikTok, in November 2022: “Cheap Charity Shops to help families all over UK. We are currently awaiting Charity registration” (transcript).

TikTok video by jaynesbabybank1_tm, 23 November 2022: Cheap Charity Shops to help families all over UK. We are currently awaiting Charity registration and started the Baby Bank during the pandemic
Her TikTok, 23 November 2022.

Who can run a charity shop?

That raises a legal question: does a charity shop have to be run by a registered charity?

The Charity Retail Association, the trade body for charity shops, was clear. Its guidance at the time said that the first step in opening a charity shop is to register with the Charity Commission, and that “Only registered charities can set up charity shops” (the guidance, May 2024). Its current page still starts the same way: “Register as a charity with the Charity Commission.”

What about a small group that has not registered? A charity can run as an unincorporated charitable association without registering while its income stays at £5,000 a year or less. Above that, GOV.UK says, a charity in England or Wales usually must register with the Charity Commission.

By her own account, Jayne’s Baby Bank had more than £8,000 from councils in 2024 alone: £7,600 from Caerphilly and Torfaen, and £1,250 from Blaenau Gwent (our report on the Brynmawr shop). That is well over the threshold, before a single sale in the shops.

Changing the name

Some listings and social media pages have since been renamed or edited to drop the words “Charity Shop”. That may be a rebrand, or a correction. But the name is still in use in many places, which leaves the public confused about what Jayne’s Baby Bank is. Donors and shoppers may reasonably ask where the money goes.

She had answered the point back in October 2022 (the post):

Her post of 24 October 2022: We have always stated and have signs up in the shops that we are going through the registration process. The sign on the door doesn't say Jaynes Baby Bank Charity, it says Jaynes Baby Bank AND Charity Shop. Once we are a charity and CIC both of which have been applied for we will change our name accordingly
Her post, 24 October 2022. Read it in our archive.

“Director of one of the largest children’s charity’s in Wales”

On 3 September 2022, the Jayne’s Baby Bank TikTok page posted this (transcript, archived copy):

when my Dad says I need to get a real job! I’m retired. director of one of the largest children’s charity’s in Wales and an influencer! 🤣

Her TikTok, 3 September 2022 (spelling as published)
TikTok video by jaynesbabybank1_tm, 3 September 2022: when my Dad says I need to get a real job! I'm retired. director of one of the largest children's charity's in Wales and an influencer!
Her TikTok, 3 September 2022.

It may have been a joke. Either way, it adds to the mixed picture. Was the claim to direct one of Wales’s largest children’s charities simply never taken down, or does it reflect what she really believes the organisation is?

What happened next

In March 2025 she wrote: “We are not a charity shop. We are a non-profit vintage, antique, and collectable shop.” We looked at that change in the attempt to erase charity shop status. The registered trade mark still reads “JAYNE’S BABY BANK & CHARITY SHOP”.

In November 2025 a community interest company, Jayne’s Baby Bank C.I.C., was incorporated at Companies House (our report). A CIC is a company, not a charity. Jayne’s Baby Bank has never been a registered charity: how to check its charity status yourself.

Sources

…Sherlock

Know someone who should read this?

Last updated

Read next

Menu

Search the articles

For her own posts and videos, use Search.

Tap where you want to zoom in. Tap again to fit.